But these guys are braver and cleverer than that and for whatever reason they thought I was right for the part. They meet when Robb captures The Crag , an ancient and decaying stronghold which serves as the seat of House Westerling. In the process of storming the castle Robb is wounded when he takes an arrow to the arm. Jeyne nurses him back to health and they grew close during that time. Robb is still there when word of the deaths of Bran and Rickon arrives though Theon Greyjoy was actually lying when he claimed they were dead.
Jeyne comforts Robb in his distress, and they end up having sex together. As she is highborn and as Robb has taken her maidenhead he is not only honor-bound to marry her, but he has fallen in love with her.
He does not suspect that the Westerlings collaborate with the Lannisters as revealed in "A Feast for Crows". Their assignment is to make Robb breach his pact with the Freys, and it is accomplished. All these events happen when Robb is in the west and are not revealed in the books until he returns with Jeyne to Riverrun.
Robb doesn't discuss breaking his marriage pact with Catelyn, and the marriage is not done in secret. Furthermore, Jeyne never becomes pregnant with Robb's heir and isn't present at the Twins during the "Red Wedding". Thus, she's alive and well afterwards, under the protection of Brynden Tully, who remains in Riverrun as Robb's Warden of the Southern Marches. Wiki Content.
Explore Wikis Community Central. Register Don't have an account? Talisa Stark. Edit source History Talk 0. I would not waste my years planning dances and masquerades with the other noble ladies.
And when I came of age I would never live in a slave city again. Talisa 2x Talisa treating the wounded after the Battle of Oxcross in " Garden of Bones. Robb and Talisa. Talisa sitting beside Robb in "The Prince of Winterfell. Robb and Talisa1. Talisa and Robb kissing in "The Prince of Winterfell. Robb and Talisa Red Wedding. Huffington Post. Interview with Oona Chaplin. Cancel Save. Universal Conquest Wiki. Season Two appearances. Garden of Bones. The Old Gods and the New.
A Man Without Honor. The Prince of Winterfell. Valar Morghulis. Season Three appearances. Valar Dohaeris. Dark Wings, Dark Words.
Walk of Punishment. On the other hand, viewers of the show got a chance to really know and care about Talisa over the course of seasons two and three.
They saw her unafraid to get her hands dirty and be on the battlefield, tending to soldiers with grotesque and life-threatening wounds. Audiences learned of her beautiful backstory that explained why she left behind the life of a noblewoman in Volantis to become a common healer in Westeros.
He not only loved her, but he truly respected her as he engaged in genuine conversation with her about battle tactics and his own inner conflicts and struggles, not to mention admiration for her healing skills and compassion. Talisa being at the wedding of Edmure Tully and Roslin Frey might not have made a lot of sense from a strategic standpoint, but having Robb see his wife and unborn child die made the Red Wedding even more shocking and devastating to witness.
By not being there, Jeyne lived on in the books, but her reappearance just felt like tying up a loose end before quickly joining the ranks of once important and now irrelevant characters in George R.
In this case, the show did a better job with Talisa than the books did with Jeyne. Bracketology: Bubble teams will be sweating these 5 conference tourneys by Mike Phillips. Next: Lady Stoneheart's absence has made Game of Thrones better. Top Stories. FanSided 2 years The war is happening at Winterfell in first official Game of Thrones season 8 trailer. FanSided 2 years Game of Thrones symbology, explained: Ice. More NFL Rumors ». View all NFL Sites.
More NBA News ». More NBA Rumors ». View all NBA Sites. More MLB News ». On the show, Robb marries Talisa just because she's hot. I think the former makes for a better and more interesting motivation.
It also ties Robb to Ned: both father and son are overly concerned with honour. View all 7 comments. Write a comment K Having finished the book, and seen the seasons on tv first, It has not bothered me at all. I think having Robb break his oath for love and having them both fall at the Red Wedding translates much better to screen then introducing a barely know house, a wife Robb marries to reserve her honour after she seduces however sweetly him, with the open question of did Jeyne ever manage to conceive Robb's child?
Though given what's alluded to with the Westerlings, i'd say a cup of Tansy Tea would put things right for the Westerlings and their daughter. Simonas In my opinion, it was not a wise decision. Because of the fact, that then you are reading the book, you are guessing: "What will Westerlings do now? Maybe it is not the end of the Starks' line if his wife is carrying a child".. So I was intrigued.. On the other hand, in TV Show.. Wife is dead, Robb has no descendants - end of story, everything is clear View 1 comment.
Andreas As Jeyne isn't really a role in the books, so noone misses her. Talisa was a bit additional soap opera drama, totally unnecessary, but didn't harm either - at least she had some character. There are other deviations that bother much more. Thibault Delavaud Yes a little.
0コメント